What the HDLC allows, what it refuses, and what buyers should check before making an offer
THE DOUGLAS ADAMS EDITORIAL SERIES
Market Insight • Property Strategy • New Orleans & Mississippi
Updated November 2026
Quick Answer
In a full-control New Orleans historic district, such as the Lower Garden District or Faubourg Marigny, you need a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Historic District Landmarks Commission (HDLC) before you replace windows visible from the street. The HDLC prefers repair, asks for documentation that historic windows are beyond repair before it approves replacement, and does not permit vinyl or aluminum windows in place of historic wood windows on street elevations. In the four districts where the HDLC reviews only demolition (Uptown, Carrollton, Mid-City and Parkview), it does not review windows, and in the French Quarter the Vieux Carré Commission applies its own rules.
Does my house fall under the HDLC?
Start with the map. The HDLC publishes its landmarks and district maps, and the answer depends on which kind of district your house sits in.
In a full-control district, the HDLC reviews any exterior part of a building visible from a public right-of-way. Its guidelines say all exterior work, excluding paint color and plantings, must be submitted for approval before work begins HDLC Design Guidelines, Introduction. Windows fall squarely inside that rule.
In a partial-control district, the City Council assigns the HDLC a narrower role. Four districts, Uptown, Parkview, Carrollton and Mid-City, are demolition review only, and the HDLC states it has no jurisdiction there beyond demolition HDLC Demolition Review FAQ. One exception buyers miss: Carrollton Avenue itself is full control.
The French Quarter is a separate case. It is governed by the Vieux Carré Commission, which has its own windows and doors guidelines.
If you are unsure what a building's rating means for the scope of review, my earlier piece on what a contributing structure means in New Orleans historic districts walks through it.
What does the HDLC require before I replace a window?
Repair first, replacement second. The HDLC's Windows and Doors guidelines strongly encourage owners to repair existing elements and, where parts have failed, to replace only the deteriorated components.
If you want to replace a full window, you will need documentation of deterioration sufficient to justify it, showing the existing windows are beyond repair. Dimensioned drawings are part of the submission, and the application runs alongside a building permit; the city notes you must file for a building permit to obtain a Certificate of Appropriateness HDLC application process. The city also asks applicants to list every exterior item they plan to touch, with location, existing material and proposed material, plus photographs of anything being replaced for poor condition.
Can I use vinyl or aluminum windows?
Not in place of historic wood windows facing the street. The guidelines state plainly: "The HDLC does not permit the replacement of historic wood windows with vinyl or aluminum windows at street elevations" HDLC Windows and Doors. Where historic sash is missing or cannot be repaired, the HDLC recommends wood replacement sash.
The rule is written for street elevations. Side and rear windows that are not visible from the street may be treated differently, so ask HDLC staff at (504) 658-7040 before you assume either way.
What about hurricane shutters?
Shutters are part of the same chapter, and they matter in a storm city. The HDLC treats operable shutters as traditional hurricane protection. Its guidelines say hurricane shutters should not be permanently installed on windows, that shutters must be operable and fill the window opening, and that roll-down hurricane shutters are not permitted. Fabric storm panels are encouraged HDLC Windows and Doors.
Does the HDLC Express Lane cover windows?
Not by name. The HDLC Express Lane issues Certificates of Appropriateness in one to three business days for work that meets the guidelines, including roof replacement (FORTIFIED roofs included), repairs and replacement to match existing, shutters, HVAC, solar, gutters and fencing. Window replacement is not on the published list. Call or email HDLC staff hdlcstaff@nola.gov before you build a closing or renovation timeline around a fast approval.
What happens if windows are replaced without approval?
It can follow the house. The HDLC guidelines state that work completed without an approved Certificate of Appropriateness is subject to possible fines, removal and restoration to the prior appearance. The HDLC issues a Stop Work Order on projects that did not receive one, the owner may have to file a retention application, and if the Commission denies it, non-compliance can lead to daily fines and liens against the property HDLC Design Guidelines, Introduction.
For a buyer, that means a set of new vinyl windows on the front of a historic house is a question to ask before closing, not after.
What should a buyer check before making an offer?
Confirm the district and level of control. Full control, demolition-only partial control, or the Vieux Carré.
Look at the street-facing windows. Original wood sash, replacement wood, or vinyl or aluminum? If the street face has vinyl or aluminum, ask the seller whether the work was approved.
Budget for repair, not just replacement. In a full-control district, plan on restoring wood windows, since replacement requires proof they are beyond repair.
Check the shutters. Operable shutters that fill the opening are what the HDLC expects; permanently mounted or roll-down systems are a flag.
Use your inspection period. Have the windows evaluated by someone who restores historic sash, and talk to HDLC staff before you commit to a renovation plan.
You can read more about the neighborhoods where these rules come up most often on my Lower Garden District and Bywater and Marigny pages.
My Perspective
I have owned several historic homes myself, and windows are one of the trade-offs every owner of an old house has to come to terms with.
Original windows are beautiful, and buyers covet them. They also come with maintenance. The sashes often need replacing. Over the course of a hundred years or more, many windows have been painted shut. If the sash weights are missing, they have to be replaced before the window will work the way it was built to. And there is an energy trade-off: historic windows do not insulate the way modern windows do.
Is it worth preserving them? Without question. The original windows are often the thing that sets a historic home apart from a house that is simply older.
FAQ
Do I need HDLC approval to repair my windows?
In a full-control district, all exterior work visible from the street except paint color and plantings must be submitted, and the city asks applicants to list repairs as well as replacements. Repairs that match existing are on the Express Lane list, which can mean approval in one to three business days.
Can I install vinyl windows on my historic New Orleans house?
Not in place of historic wood windows on street elevations in an HDLC district. The HDLC recommends wood replacement sash where historic sash cannot be repaired.
Does the HDLC review windows in Uptown or Mid-City?
No. Uptown, Parkview, Carrollton and Mid-City are demolition review only, so the HDLC does not review windows there. Carrollton Avenue itself is full control.
Who reviews windows in the French Quarter?
The Vieux Carré Commission, under its own design guidelines.
What if the previous owner replaced windows without approval?
Unapproved work can lead to a Stop Work Order, a retention application, removal and restoration, and, if not resolved, daily fines and liens against the property. Ask before closing.
The Bottom Line
In most of the city's historic districts, windows are not a simple swap. If the house is in a full-control district and the windows face the street, plan on repair, expect wood if replacement is approved, and get HDLC sign-off before any work starts. For buyers, the windows on the front of the house can tell you a great deal about what the next owner will inherit.
Thinking about buying or selling a historic house in New Orleans? Let's talk about what the windows, shutters and HDLC history mean for your plans.
Douglas Adams
Douglas Adams Real Estate with Crescent Sotheby's International Realty
617 Julia St, New Orleans, LA 70130 | 504-444-8670
Each Office Is Independently Owned and Operated
About the Author
Douglas Adams is a Global Real Estate Advisor with Crescent Sotheby's International Realty serving Louisiana and the Mississippi Gulf Coast.
Through The Douglas Adams Editorial Series, he explores the history, architecture, neighborhoods, and communities that make the Gulf South such a remarkable place to call home. Every article is informed by firsthand experience, original photography, professional research, and a passion for telling the stories that exist beyond the front door.
Sources
City of New Orleans, Historic District Landmarks Commission, Design Guidelines: Introduction
City of New Orleans, Historic District Landmarks Commission, Design Guidelines: Windows and Doors
City of New Orleans, Historic District Landmarks Commission, Demolition Review in Local Historic Districts FAQ
City of New Orleans, Historic District Landmarks Commission, Application Process
City of New Orleans, Historic District Landmarks Commission, Landmarks and Districts Maps
City of New Orleans, New Orleans and CBD HDLC Express Lane November 13, 2025
City of New Orleans, Vieux Carré Commission, Design Guidelines: Windows and Doors
